Opened 14 years ago

Closed 13 years ago

Last modified 13 years ago

#25 closed clarification (fixed)

Version negotiation/backwards compatibility

Reported by: pasi.eronen@… Owned by:
Priority: minor Milestone:
Component: draft-ietf-tls-rfc4346-bis Version: 03
Severity: Keywords:
Cc:

Description

http://www1.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/tls/current/msg00866.html http://www1.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/tls/current/msg00854.html http://www1.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/tls/current/msg00851.html

In Section 6.2.1, when describing the version field, add the following text:

Note that a client that supports multiple versions of TLS
may not know what version will be employed before it
receives ServerHello.  See Appendix E for discussion about
what record layer version number should be employed for
ClientHello.

E.1. Compatibility with TLS 1.0/1.1 and SSL 3.0

Since there are various versions of TLS (1.0, 1.1, 1.2, and
any future versions) and SSL (2.0 and 3.0), means are needed
to negotiate the specific protocol version to use.  The TLS
protocol provides a built-in mechanism for version
negotiation so as not to bother other protocol components
with the complexities of version selection.

TLS versions 1.0, 1.1, and 1.2, and SSL 3.0 are very
similar, and use compatible ClientHello messages; thus,
supporting all of them is relatively easy.  Similarly,
servers can easily handle clients trying to use future
versions of TLS as long as the ClientHello format remains
compatible, and the client support the highest protocol
version available in the server.

A TLS 1.2 client who wishes to negotiate with such older
servers will send a normal TLS 1.2 ClientHello, containing 
{ 3, 3 } (TLS 1.2) in ClientHello.client_version. If the
server does not support this version, it will respond with
ServerHello containing an older version number. If the
client agrees to use this version, the negotiation will
proceed as appropriate for the negotiated protocol.

If the version chosen by the server is not supported by the
client (or not acceptable), the client MUST send a
"protocol_version" alert message and close the connection.

If a TLS server receives a ClientHello containing a version
number greater than the highest version supported by the
server, it MUST reply according to the highest version
supported by the server.

A TLS server can also receive a ClientHello containing
version number smaller than the highest supported
version. If the server wishes to negotiate with old clients,
it will proceed as appropriate for the highest version
supported by the server that is not greater than
ClientHello.client_version. For example, if the server
supports TLS 1.0, 1.1, and 1.2, and client_version is TLS
1.0, the server will proceed with a TLS 1.0 ServerHello. If
server supports (or is willing to use) only versions greater
than client_version, it MUST send a "protocol_version" alert
message and close the connection.

Whenever a client already knows the highest protocol known
to a server (for example, when resuming a session), it
SHOULD initiate the connection in that native protocol.

   Note: some server implementations are known to implement
   version negotiation incorrectly. For example, there are
   buggy TLS 1.0 servers that simply close the connection
   when the client offers a version newer than TLS
   1.0. Also, it is known that some servers will refuse
   connection if any TLS extensions are included in
   ClientHello.

   Interoperability with such buggy servers is a complex
   topic beyond the scope of this document, and may require
   multiple connection attempts by the client.

Earlier versions of the TLS specification were not fully
clear on what the record layer version number
(TLSPlaintext.version) should contain when sending
ClientHello (i.e., before it is known which version of the
protocol will be employed). Thus, TLS servers compliant with
this specification MUST accept any value {03,XX} as the
record layer version number for ClientHello.

TLS clients that wish to negotiate with older servers MAY
send any value {03,XX} as the record layer version
number. Typical values would be {03,00}, the lowest version
number supported by the client, and the value of
ClientHello.client_version. No single value will guarantee
interoperability with all old servers, but this is a complex
topic beyond the scope of this document.

http://www1.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/tls/current/msg00985.html

E.2 Compatibility with SSL 2.0

TLS 1.2 clients that wish to support SSL 2.0 servers MUST
send version 2.0 CLIENT-HELLO messages defined in
[SSL2]. The message MUST contain the same version number as
would be used for ordinary ClientHello, and MUST encode the
supported TLS ciphersuites in the CIPHER-SPECS-DATA field as
described below.

   Warning: The ability to send version 2.0 CLIENT-HELLO messages
   will be phased out with all due haste, since the newer
   ClientHello format provides better mechanisms for moving to
   newer versions and negotiating extensions.  TLS 1.2 clients
   SHOULD NOT support SSL 2.0.

However, even TLS servers that do not support SSL 2.0 SHOULD
accept version 2.0 CLIENT-HELLO messages. The message is
presented below in sufficient detail for TLS server
implementors; the true definition is still assumed to be
[SSL2].

For negotiation purposes, 2.0 CLIENT-HELLO is interpreted
the same way as a ClientHello with a "null" compression
method and no extensions. Note that this message MUST be
sent directly on the wire, not wrapped as a TLS record. For
the purposes of calculating Finished and CertificateVerify,
the msg_length field is not considered to be a part of the
handshake message.

    uint8 V2CipherSpec[3];

    struct {
        uint16 msg_length;
        uint8 msg_type;
        ProtocolVersion version;
        uint16 cipher_spec_length;
        uint16 session_id_length;
        uint16 challenge_length;
        V2CipherSpec cipher_specs[V2ClientHello.cipher_spec_length];
        opaque session_id[V2ClientHello.session_id_length];
        opaque challenge[V2ClientHello.challenge_length;
    } V2ClientHello;

msg_length
    The highest bit MUST be 1; the remaining bits contain the 
    length of the following data in bytes. 

msg_type
    The message type for V2ClientHello is one (1).

version
    Equal to ClientHello.client_version.

cipher_spec_length
    This field is the total length of the field cipher_specs. 
    It cannot be zero and MUST be a multiple of the 
    V2CipherSpec length (3).

session_id_length
    The length of the session_id field in bytes; MUST be zero
    for a client that claims to support TLS 1.2.

challenge_length 
    The length of the challenge field in bytes; MUST be between
    16 and 32 (inclusive).

cipher_specs
    This is a list of all CipherSpecs the client is willing and
    able to use. In addition to the 2.0 cipher specs defined in
    [SSL2], this includes the TLS cipher suites normally sent in
    ClientHello.cipher_suites, each cipher suite prefixed by a 
    zero byte. For example, TLS ciphersuite {0x00,0x0A} would be 
    sent as {0x00,0x00,0x0A}.

session_id
    This field MUST be empty.

challenge
    Corresponds to ClientHello.random. If the challenge length
    is less than 32, the TLS server will pad the data with 
    leading (note: not trailing) zero bytes to make it 32 bytes 
    long.

Note: Requests to resume a TLS session MUST use a TLS client
hello.

Change History (5)

comment:1 Changed 14 years ago by pasi.eronen@…

  • Milestone set to milestone1

comment:2 Changed 14 years ago by ekr@…

  • Resolution set to fixed
  • Status changed from new to closed

comment:3 Changed 14 years ago by pasi.eronen@…

  • Milestone milestone1 deleted
  • Resolution fixed deleted
  • Status changed from closed to reopened
  • Version changed from 02 to 03

Text in -03 is not yet consistent: 1) doesn't make sense to say that msg_type SHOULD be 1; it IS one if this is a V2 clienthello, 2) text about challenge length is not consistent (discussed on the list); 3) typo/grammar in session_id_length field.

comment:4 Changed 13 years ago by ekr@…

  • Resolution set to fixed
  • Status changed from reopened to closed

comment:5 Changed 13 years ago by ekr@…

Fixed

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.