Timeline


and

Jun 16, 2006:

9:48 AM Ticket #68 (Security section should discuss MN identity, not security of network ...) closed by kempf@…
fixed: I haven't seen any discussion on this, so I am going to remove the …

Jun 15, 2006:

3:22 PM Ticket #85 (Assumes DHCP can't be used when it could) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Fixed.
2:52 PM Ticket #84 (Statement on Mobile IP is unnecessary) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Removed the assumption about Mobile IP but kept the rest of the …
2:48 PM Ticket #83 (Modify language in multiple wireless technology support section) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Changed.
2:43 PM Ticket #82 (Remove "IP Link" terminology) closed by kempf@…
fixed
2:37 PM Ticket #76 (Clarify Goal #7: Support for Heterogeneous Link Technologies) closed by kempf@…
invalid: Issue #83 suggests some improvements in the text, but there have been …
2:35 PM Ticket #74 (Add Goal for Data Plane Configurable Forwarding) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Added.
2:27 PM Ticket #86 (DHCP is a mobility management protocol too (for Gap analysis)) closed by kempf@…
wontfix: The gap analysis is supposed to be for protocols that a) have in the …
2:20 PM Ticket #86 (DHCP is a mobility management protocol too (for Gap analysis)) created by kempf@…
Fred Templin says: 5) Section 9, "DHCP + IP forwarding table …
2:19 PM Ticket #85 (Assumes DHCP can't be used when it could) created by kempf@…
Fred Templin says: 4) Section 9.3.1, under Goal #6, sentence …
2:17 PM Ticket #84 (Statement on Mobile IP is unnecessary) created by kempf@…
Fred Templin says: 3) Section 2.8, second paragraph, sentence …
2:14 PM Ticket #83 (Modify language in multiple wireless technology support section) created by kempf@…
Fred Templin says: 2) Section 2.7, paragraph beginning: "In …
2:12 PM Ticket #82 (Remove "IP Link" terminology) created by kempf@…
Fred Templin says: 1) The term "IP link" is used extensively …

Jun 12, 2006:

9:22 AM Ticket #80 (Change "IP Link" to "IP Domain") closed by kempf@…
fixed
9:12 AM Ticket #79 (Editoral Changes for the PS draft from Fred Templin) closed by kempf@…
fixed
9:08 AM Ticket #78 (DHCP is a mobility management protocol too) closed by kempf@…
fixed

Jun 9, 2006:

1:26 PM Ticket #81 (Change "Interoperable IP protocols" to "Mobile IP based protocols") closed by kempf@…
wontfix: It has been argued on the list that HMIP and FMIP could be used in non …
1:22 PM Ticket #81 (Change "Interoperable IP protocols" to "Mobile IP based protocols") created by kempf@…
Fred Templin writes: 11) Section 4.0, first paragraph. Change: "1) …
12:57 PM Ticket #80 (Change "IP Link" to "IP Domain") created by kempf@…
Fred Templin suggests: 6) Section 1.1, the term "IP link" is …
10:20 AM Ticket #79 (Editoral Changes for the PS draft from Fred Templin) created by kempf@…
3) Section 1.0, insert paragraph break before: "Firstly ...". 4) …
9:45 AM Ticket #78 (DHCP is a mobility management protocol too) created by kempf@…
Fred Templin says: 2) Section 1.0, need to mention DHCP and others as …
9:43 AM Ticket #75 (Add goal for network-based load balancing) closed by kempf@…
wontfix: Load balancing between wireless cells is traditionally done in radio …
9:36 AM Ticket #77 (Questioning Contributors Section) closed by kempf@…
invalid: Please read Section 2.12 points 1, 2, and 4 in …
9:31 AM Ticket #77 (Questioning Contributors Section) created by kempf@…
Fred Templin says: 1) It seems odd to have a "Contributers" section …

Jun 6, 2006:

9:54 AM Ticket #76 (Clarify Goal #7: Support for Heterogeneous Link Technologies) created by kempf@…
Eric Njedjou writes: The " support for heterogeneous wireless link …
9:50 AM Ticket #75 (Add goal for network-based load balancing) created by kempf@…
Eric Njedjou writes: Generally the network provider would like to …
9:22 AM Ticket #58 (IGP solution problems are not accurate.) closed by kempf@…
fixed: While the Cisco web page gives a more detailed description of how to …
9:21 AM Ticket #58 (IGP solution problems are not accurate.) reopened by kempf@…
9:19 AM Ticket #55 (Define desired scalability more precisely) closed by kempf@…
wontfix: No concensus for adding a quantitative limit on scalability. Some …

Jun 1, 2006:

12:03 AM Ticket #46 (Editorial Changes in REQ draft by Gab Montenegro) closed by kempf@…
fixed: I did the best I could with these, but some of these comments are …

May 31, 2006:

10:18 PM Ticket #42 (Editorial Changes for REQ draft from Pete McCann) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Fixed
9:43 PM Ticket #38 (Editorial changes for the REQ draft from Jukka Manner) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Fixed.
9:41 PM Ticket #32 (Editorial changes for REQ draft from Phil Eardley) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Fixed.
5:16 AM Ticket #58 (IGP solution problems are not accurate.) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Remove this text from both the PS and REQ drafts since although this …
5:05 AM Ticket #31 (Add fault tolerance and robustness to the REQ draft) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Fixed.
5:04 AM Ticket #66 (Quantify handover performance delay) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Fixed.
4:47 AM Ticket #73 (Editorial Changes for REQ draft from Pekka Savola) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Fixed. SEND calls the certs "routing authorization certificates" so …
4:33 AM Ticket #72 (Clarify comment on wired networks resource requirements) closed by kempf@…
fixed: This is a typo. I think this should say: While bandwidth and router …
4:29 AM Ticket #71 (Mention header compression software requirement on the host) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Add the following after this phrase: "Header compression also …
4:26 AM Ticket #67 (Link local address uniqueness) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Add the following text to Section 2.2, point 4 at the end of the first …
4:21 AM Ticket #34 (Add Goal: "Localised mobility management independent of global ...) closed by kempf@…
fixed
4:07 AM Ticket #26 (link-local scoping in a NetLMM domain is undefined) closed by julien.ietf@…
fixed: Resolution: Adopt the proposed resolution by adding the following …
4:05 AM Ticket #74 (Add Goal for Data Plane Configurable Forwarding) created by kempf@…
James Kempf writes: I would like to add the following text as a goal …
1:19 AM Ticket #58 (IGP solution problems are not accurate.) reopened by kempf@…
Reopened, awaiting Pekka Savola's comment about validity of Cisco's …
1:10 AM Ticket #57 (Scenerio should include WLAN) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Text has been added.
1:00 AM Ticket #57 (Scenerio should include WLAN) reopened by kempf@…
Change the following text in Section 3.1: One scenario where …

May 30, 2006:

6:28 AM Ticket #25 (MN-AR interface specifying REDIRECT behavior) closed by julien.ietf@…
fixed: Fred Templin wrote: One attribute of a multi-link subnet (which I …
6:26 AM Ticket #25 (MN-AR interface specifying REDIRECT behavior) reopened by julien.ietf@…
1:34 AM Ticket #25 (MN-AR interface specifying REDIRECT behavior) closed by julien.ietf@…
fixed: Fred Templin wrote: One attribute of a multi-link subnet (which I …

May 25, 2006:

12:11 AM Ticket #73 (Editorial Changes for REQ draft from Pekka Savola) created by kempf@…
==> one author too many.. ==> In some cases, you've used "routing" …
12:10 AM Ticket #72 (Clarify comment on wired networks resource requirements) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: While bandwidth and router processing …
12:09 AM Ticket #71 (Mention header compression software requirement on the host) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: While header compression technology can …
12:07 AM Ticket #70 (Can IP handover be performed via Link Layer means?) closed by kempf@…
invalid: Yes, it is used in UTRAN, for example, for GPRS. The cdma2K networks …
12:06 AM Ticket #70 (Can IP handover be performed via Link Layer means?) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: If link layer support exists for IP level …
12:05 AM Ticket #69 (Need to include gap analysis for IGP/BGP + tunnel) closed by kempf@…
invalid: Pekka's comment on the PS draft seemed to indicate that this solution …
12:02 AM Ticket #69 (Need to include gap analysis for IGP/BGP + tunnel) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 6) I didn't read the appendix except for section …
12:01 AM Ticket #68 (Security section should discuss MN identity, not security of network ...) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 4) section 2.3 discusses the threat where the …

May 24, 2006:

11:57 PM Ticket #67 (Link local address uniqueness) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 3) section 2.2: I guess the assumption is that …
11:52 PM Ticket #66 (Quantify handover performance delay) created by kempf@…
2) section 2.1 discusses handover performance improvement, but also …
11:50 PM Ticket #65 (Will QoS, multicast, and dormant mode/paging always be out of scope?) closed by kempf@…
invalid: These are intended to be covered during rechartering after the initial …
11:49 PM Ticket #65 (Will QoS, multicast, and dormant mode/paging always be out of scope?) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 1) section 2 rules out of scope from initial …
12:51 PM Ticket #64 (Description of existing solutions in Section 4 does not give ...) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Added a once sentence description of deployment status for each protocol.
12:41 PM Ticket #64 (Description of existing solutions in Section 4 does not give ...) created by kempf@…
> > Existing solutions for localized mobility management, which …
12:38 PM Ticket #51 (Use of HMIP and FMIP with other global mobility protocols) closed by kempf@…
fixed
12:38 PM Ticket #51 (Use of HMIP and FMIP with other global mobility protocols) reopened by kempf@…
Vijay says: > > While it is possible that mobile nodes with these …
2:57 AM Ticket #58 (IGP solution problems are not accurate.) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Added references and the following qualifier after the list of …
2:51 AM Ticket #56 (Document language is wireless specific) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Added the following qualifier as the last sentence in the …
2:50 AM Ticket #62 (Security considerations section) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Changed the Security Considerations to: Localized mobility management …
2:34 AM Ticket #57 (Scenerio should include WLAN) closed by kempf@…
wontfix: Actually, large WLAN networks are covered by Scenerio 1. The text "or …
2:32 AM Ticket #54 (Add short discussion on lack of scalability for a single link WLAN network) closed by kempf@…
invalid: Isn't this covered by the text "or in which it is not possible to …
2:29 AM Ticket #52 (Editorial Comments on the PS draft from Vijay) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Done.
2:22 AM Ticket #59 (Problem statement doesn't mention IPv4) closed by kempf@…
fixed
1:56 AM Ticket #51 (Use of HMIP and FMIP with other global mobility protocols) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Added the following text after the sentence beginning "Firstly...": …
1:31 AM Ticket #63 (Replace security text for HMIP) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Done.
1:30 AM Ticket #53 (Add Reference to MIP6 Location Privacy Draft) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Done.

May 23, 2006:

11:07 PM Ticket #50 (Change Abstract to better reflect contents) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Changed the abstract to be: Localized mobility management is a well …
11:06 PM Ticket #16 (Add backward compatibility requirement) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Requirement was added to 01 document.
11:04 PM Ticket #49 (Change Title to reflect contents) closed by kempf@…
fixed: Done.
11:03 PM Ticket #60 (Access Network Definition is not acceptable) closed by kempf@…
fixed: I took a look at Section 3, paragraphs 1, 2, and 3 in RFC 3753 and, …
10:36 PM Ticket #63 (Replace security text for HMIP) created by kempf@…
Vijay writes: I would replace the following 4) Security for the …
5:48 AM Ticket #62 (Security considerations section) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 5.0 Security Considerations Localized …
5:46 AM Ticket #61 (Architecture description included in problem statement) closed by kempf@…
wontfix: The charter includes a description of the solution architecture which …
5:45 AM Ticket #61 (Architecture description included in problem statement) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: Mobility routing anchor points within the …
5:43 AM Ticket #60 (Access Network Definition is not acceptable) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: Access Network (revised) An …
5:39 AM Ticket #59 (Problem statement doesn't mention IPv4) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 5) The problem statement and IPv4 The charter …
5:30 AM Ticket #58 (IGP solution problems are not accurate.) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 4) Solution 3 (IGP host routes) problems are not …
4:20 AM Ticket #57 (Scenerio should include WLAN) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 3) Scenarios doesn't mention the typical large …
4:17 AM Ticket #56 (Document language is wireless specific) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 2) the language is wireless-specific In this …
3:57 AM Ticket #55 (Define desired scalability more precisely) created by kempf@…
Pekka Savola writes: 1) scaling requirements/problem space is not …

May 22, 2006:

12:41 PM Ticket #54 (Add short discussion on lack of scalability for a single link WLAN network) created by kempf@…
Vijay says: > 3.1 Large Campus with Diverse Physical …
12:36 PM Ticket #53 (Add Reference to MIP6 Location Privacy Draft) created by kempf@…
Vijay says: > 3) Location privacy. The change in temporary …
12:34 PM Ticket #52 (Editorial Comments on the PS draft from Vijay) created by kempf@…
> Global Mobility Management Protocol > A Global …
12:05 PM Ticket #51 (Use of HMIP and FMIP with other global mobility protocols) created by kempf@…
From Vijay: > Localized mobility management has been the topic …
12:03 PM Ticket #50 (Change Abstract to better reflect contents) created by kempf@…
From Vijay: > Abstract > > This document examines the …
12:01 PM Ticket #49 (Change Title to reflect contents) created by kempf@…
> Problem Statement for IP Local Mobility …
Note: See TracTimeline for information about the timeline view.