Timeline


and

08/03/13:

22:19 Ticket #34 (Review) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: The applicability of these early review comments to the -07 draft is …
22:17 Ticket #35 (Follow-up of the -02 version) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: Going back to this old ticket, and re-reading it against the -07. The …
20:58 Ticket #36 (Comments on "draft-iab-dns-applications-00") closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: Looking back over old tickets here, reading these comments against the …
19:39 Ticket #15 (Sections 4.3.1 and 5) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: We now allude to this nightmare in the draft in more detail, for …
19:37 Ticket #16 (Section 4.2) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: This was fixed back in -02, and while I know that the send-n draft is …
19:29 Ticket #13 (Review) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: The guidance text is much changed from this revision, and now makes …
19:24 Ticket #38 (Comments on draft-iab-dns-applications-01) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: Based on John's later and more favorable comments about the …
19:19 Ticket #74 (Comments on draft-iab-dns-applications-02) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed
19:12 Ticket #206 (Comments on -05) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: These fixes were implemented in -06. The guidance bullets are …
19:06 Ticket #180 (Review) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: Replied to these comments on October 18, 2012. These fixes were …
19:00 Ticket #156 (Dave's Review) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: Fixes were implemented in -05.
18:56 Ticket #195 (Comment on "Architectural Considerations on Application Features in ...) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: We discussed over email in October 2012, fixes went into the -06 …
18:03 Ticket #204 (Comments) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: This is probably a bit too conservative to reflect the realities of …
17:59 Ticket #210 (Comments regarding draft-iab-dns-applications-05) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: Responded to these comments (October 21, 2012) and implemented fixes …
17:53 Ticket #165 (Bernard's review) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: Implemented fixes for these in -07. Sometimes in concert with other …
17:47 Ticket #237 (Section 1) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: (mostly) fixed in -07; on the string transformation, the FWKR is …
17:44 Ticket #238 (Section 2) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed: (mostly) fixed in -07; I left the first as-is because that section …
17:35 Ticket #179 (draft-iab-dns-applications-05 is a bit short on alternatives) closed by jon.peterson@…
fixed
00:33 Ticket #290 (Feedback from Jeff Hodges on draft-iab-identifier-comparison-07) closed by dthaler@…
fixed: > so here's my somewhat incomplete notes fyi/fwiw in case they are …

07/03/13:

20:52 Ticket #270 (Resources associated with allowing UTF-8 in RFCs (Section 3.3)) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed: The text for the ASCII requirement has been modified to: * …
20:48 Ticket #269 (Discussion of UTF-8 in RFCs (Section 3.3)) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed: After further discussion with the RSOC concerning the text of 3.2, the …
18:01 Ticket #260 (Comments) closed by hlflanagan@…
wontfix: No further input received on this ticket. Closing.
17:49 Ticket #247 (Comments) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed: No further comments received on this ticket, so with the clarification …
17:48 Ticket #246 (Marc Blanchet review) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed: No further comments have been received, and doc has been modified as …
17:46 Ticket #245 (Dave Thaler's review of draft-iab-rfcformatreq) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed: I believe all items other than UTF-8 have been resolved, and the UTF-8 …
17:44 Ticket #263 (Arguments against markup are no good) closed by hlflanagan@…
wontfix: No further responses received. Closing ticket.
17:32 Ticket #271 (Clarity and Editorial: Section 3.3 and elsewhere) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed: No further comment received on this particular item. Closing.
15:28 Ticket #298 (Sections 3.1.3, 3.2.2, 3.2.3) created by housley@…
In section 3.1.3, the structure comparison should be more like this: …

06/03/13:

17:38 Ticket #297 (Comments on draft-iab-filtering-considerations) created by dthaler@…
I have a number of fairly substantial comments on this document. See …
16:51 Ticket #285 (BCP references) closed by spencer@…
fixed: Agreed. Fixed in -04.
03:54 Ticket #296 (Dave Thaler review of -03) created by spencer@…
These are Dave's comments received during IAB Last Call.

04/03/13:

18:05 Ticket #264 (Comments on -02) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed
18:04 Ticket #265 (No Updates: header) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed
18:04 Ticket #292 (Update of RFC history) closed by hlflanagan@…
wontfix
18:03 Ticket #293 (Examples described for Applicability) closed by hlflanagan@…
wontfix
18:03 Ticket #294 (file size) closed by hlflanagan@…
wontfix
18:02 Ticket #295 (I-D that are not related to one Area or WG) closed by hlflanagan@…
wontfix
18:02 Ticket #272 (Editorial / formatting nit) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed
18:02 Ticket #273 (A rigorous memo) closed by hlflanagan@…
fixed

01/03/13:

19:11 Ticket #295 (I-D that are not related to one Area or WG) created by abdussalambaryun@…
I got information in IETF that sometimes an I-D may becomes related to …
19:08 Ticket #294 (file size) created by daedulus@…
I think that this I-D has one hole in it but it is a massive one. It …
19:06 Ticket #293 (Examples described for Applicability) created by abdussalambaryun@…
As I understand that there are sections that must be included in the …
19:00 Ticket #292 (Update of RFC history) created by abdussalambaryun@…
Some RFC I read I get into confuse what is the history of update and …

27/02/13:

00:55 Ticket #291 (Alissa's review) created by acooper@…
Edits and comments are attached. It strikes me as a bit odd that 2.3 …

26/02/13:

00:13 Ticket #290 (Feedback from Jeff Hodges on draft-iab-identifier-comparison-07) created by Jeff.Hodges@…
overall: the overall goal of the doc is arguably ensconced in the …

25/02/13:

21:24 Ticket #259 (Adrian's review) closed by acooper@…
fixed
14:06 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
01:13 Ticket #289 (Section 3.4.2) created by bernard_aboba@…
[BA] Section 2 of the document states: One of the primary drivers …
00:57 Ticket #288 (Section 3.5 Expert Review) created by bernard_aboba@…
The IESG members use expert reviews as a means to solicit the …
00:25 Ticket #287 (Section 3.6.1) created by bernard_aboba@…
This section points to the web page where IETF liaison managers are …
00:17 Ticket #286 (Section A.2) created by bernard_aboba@…
Given the issues referred to in RFC 4441 Section A.2.3, I'd recommend …
00:06 Ticket #285 (BCP references) created by bernard_aboba@…
References to BCPs are handled inconsistently within the document. For …

24/02/13:

23:59 Ticket #284 (Section 6.2: Ethertype Allocations requested by IESG) created by bernard_aboba@…
RFC 4441 Section 1.8 contains the following text: While a fee is …
23:44 Ticket #283 (Section 3.1) created by bernard_aboba@…
This section is 5 pages long, duplicating material found in web pages …
23:26 Ticket #282 (Section 6.2) created by bernard_aboba@…
Given the proposed OUI Registry Restructuring (see …
07:37 Ticket #281 (Comments) created by hsantos@…
Hi, with a quick review, and many comments and points, I think the one …
00:11 Ticket #277 (Review of -07) closed by dthaler@…
fixed: > Re …
00:10 Ticket #280 (Jeff Hodges feedback on referencing RFC 6125) closed by dthaler@…
fixed: I think this point is important enough to include early in the doc, so …
00:09 Ticket #268 (Comments) closed by dthaler@…
fixed: > For example, as has been pointed out on these lists before, > …
00:06 Ticket #256 (Comments on draft-iab-identifier-comparison-07) closed by dthaler@…
fixed: > > Abstract > > > > Identifiers such as hostnames, URIs, and email …

23/02/13:

20:24 Ticket #280 (Jeff Hodges feedback on referencing RFC 6125) created by dthaler@…
I'm taking a look at draft-iab-identifier-comparison and notice that …
16:57 Ticket #279 (SM's comments) created by acooper@…
In Section 1: 'With regard to data, often it is a concept applied to …

22/02/13:

21:45 Ticket #278 (IEEE 802.11 early review of -03) created by spencer@…
IEEE 802.11 has provided comments for this draft, in spreadsheet …
08:16 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
08:09 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
08:08 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
08:07 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
08:04 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
08:02 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
08:00 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
07:59 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
07:58 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
07:55 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
07:53 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
07:49 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
05:37 pots.jpg attached to WikiStart by bernard_aboba@…
End of POTS

19/02/13:

23:59 WikiStart edited by marc.blanchet@…
some formatting. (diff)
23:15 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
23:14 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
23:12 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
23:11 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
23:10 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
20:42 WikiStart edited by bernard_aboba@…
(diff)
19:31 Ticket #277 (Review of -07) created by derhoermi@…
In section 3.3 there is Also, when a URI is embedded in plain text …
16:10 Ticket #276 (Minor editorial changes on draft-iab-rfc4441rev-02) closed by spencer@…
fixed: Fixed in -03.
15:16 Ticket #276 (Minor editorial changes on draft-iab-rfc4441rev-02) created by spencer@…
From Dan Romanescu: I am fine with the proposed changes, I have only …

18/02/13:

22:35 Ticket #240 (Introduction) closed by spencer@…
fixed: I started with the text Bernard suggested, and ended up with this in …
21:44 Ticket #253 (Review of draft-dawkins-iab-rfc4441rev-02) closed by spencer@…
fixed
21:42 Ticket #184 (RFC 4441bis Thoughts) closed by spencer@…
fixed
21:34 Ticket #183 (RFC 4441 Comments) closed by spencer@…
fixed

17/02/13:

18:02 Ticket #267 (Missing solution discussion) reopened by bernard_aboba@…

13/02/13:

15:03 Ticket #267 (Missing solution discussion) closed by hannes.tschofenig@…
fixed: I initially tried to have the workshop agenda more or less reflected …

11/02/13:

18:35 Ticket #275 (Dean Willis' comments) created by acooper@…
There's also a second aspect of "identifiability" relating to "traffic …

08/02/13:

22:44 Ticket #274 (Stephen Farrell's comments) created by acooper@…
While I agree that endpoint based blocking is maybe least-bad …
Note: See TracTimeline for information about the timeline view.